Thank you guys!
Of course I was driving to work today and noticed my temps were crazy high. Parked it, didn't think much of it. Drove it home.
By the time I got to my house temps were crazy high again (220 on my mechanical gauge and 240 in HP Tuners... not dangerous, but way outside of the comfortable zone). Popped the hood, and noticed there was something I didn't hear... my fan. Checked HP Tuners and it was setup properly, and I can hear the relay opening and closing. So either it's the wiring (doubtful) or the fan shit the bed. LUCKILY, for some reason we have 4 of the exact same 16" SPAL fans at work that I can borrow for troubleshooting. So, going to do that tomorrow or Wednesday and see what happens.
All in all though I love the look of the car with the hood on. Just need to figure out the fan, throw in the pump and finish getting the tune.